Canadian & British Tea Service in the Heart of Lynchburg
By: Izzi Diaz Young | Photos By: Ashlee Glen
A place known and loved by all in Lynchburg stood at 1215 Commerce Street for fourteen years. A place where pinkies were raised, cups were poured, and forever memories were created: The Ploughcroft Tea Room. More than a Lynchburg staple, it was a treasure to all who visited.
When the news rang of its closure after over a decade, Cheryl Carter and Anthony (Tony) Quaranta knew it was time to start brewing the next chapter in their own lives, becoming owners of The Maple Leaf Tea Room.
Now open at the identical address but with a new title, The Maple Leaf Tea Room has the same exact warm-hug-feeling as it did before. Serving lunch, pouring afternoon tea, and providing a cozy ambience to all who enter, this renovated spot is the perfect location for all ages to come and enjoy a cuppa.
Hailing from Saint John, New Brunswick, Canada, owner Cheryl Carter and her partner, Tony Quaranta are the newest tea sommeliers on the block. Carter relocated to Lynchburg in 1988, around the same time Quaranta found himself in the city as well.
Quaranta, owner of The Little Dinner Theater Players, was introduced to The Ploughcroft Tea Room years ago as a result of producing several dinner theater performances at the venue.
“We had been friends with the owner, Patricia Hutto, for several years before I came to work for her part time a few years ago,” stated Carter. “I had been working as a sort of assistant manager for Ms. Pat when she announced that she would be retiring after fourteen years, and closing The Ploughcroft in December of 2024. After her announcement, the outpouring of sadness that there would no longer be a tea room in Lynchburg was really quite amazing. So many of her patrons came in the last few months that it was beyond busy, and we did our best to accommodate everyone who wanted to come one last time.”
This display of love and admiration for the tea room pulled on Carter’s heartstrings, signaling that maybe this beloved place’s story wasn’t over quite yet, and that she might be the one to continue it.
“I was frequently asked if I would purchase the restaurant and continue the tea room, but at the time it hadn’t been something I was considering,” Carter noted. The former owner, Patricia Hutto, had dubbed the name The Ploughcroft tea room in honor of her family home, and had no plans to transfer the name alongside the restaurant when the time came.
“With so many people asking, and hoping that someone would take up the mantle, Tony and I decided to give it a go,” Carter remarked. “Afternoon tea is also a Canadian tradition, and my Canadian heritage is from the British Isles, so The Maple Leaf Tea Room was born.”
Upon opening its doors, the space now welcomes guests with the perfect essence. From gorgeous decorative teapots to vintage furniture, the tone for your visit will be instantly set.
“We wanted to keep the eclectic feel, and being theater folk, we love a theme,” Carter noted. “So, an Anne of Green Gables vibe was included, with fresh paint and antique decor. I’m super happy with how the dining room feels so cozy and warm.”
For fans of the old Ploughcroft menu, there are a few old staples that outlived the transformation to Maple Leaf.
Carter remarked that some of the lunch favorites on the current menu do remain the same as before, all of their offerings include something for everyone.
The mouthwatering lunch cuisine is served from 11:00 a.m. through 1:30 p.m., where visitors can expect a range of salads, pies, scones, and much more. Carter noted that they have even included a few new delicacies as a nod to her Canadian background, such as poutine and Halifax donairs. Although the cooking area is a wheat kitchen, there are also now a few gluten-free options on the lineup for those with any allergies.
“Afternoon tea is much the same, except we now include Canadian and English sweet treats,” Carter stated. “Following with the Anne of Green Gables theme, we also offer sparkling raspberry cordial, black currant herbal iced tea, and sparkling lemonade.”
To enjoy all of these delectable menu offerings, reservations are not required, but Carter highly recommends making them to ensure the utmost enjoyment out of your experience.
“Tea is meant to be spent time on,” she said. She advises those planning their visits to make arrangements by calling, emailing, or messaging the business’ social media directly.
When asked what else visitors can expect from the tea room other than old-fashioned fun and herbal infusions, Carter noted, “The Room offers a cozy atmosphere all throughout the year, and we have great fun decorating for the holidays.”
The future of the tea room is only getting brighter, too. They now offer private party rentals on Sundays, perfect for any celebration or event. From baby showers to engagement parties, birthdays, and more, Maple Leaf is a must-book location.
Carter looked forward to the future, stating, “We plan on having live music from time to time, and keep an eye out for special ‘tea’ events!”
The legacy of The Ploughcroft Tea Room—a destination that served Lynchburg over a decade—lives on within stories shared across the city still today. From past celebrations to memories made over a cuppa, the afterglow of this place’s impact remains ever present.
Now, these memories can still be cherished while new ones are created. Fresh moments in The Maple Leaf Tea Room will blossom like florals, forever linked to the magic made within its walls. Maple Leaf is a fresh pot ready to be poured, welcoming visitors from across the city and beyond who will soon be enchanted by the warmth of it, whether it be found within the ambiance, the cups of tea, or the people inside.
On their menu is a quote by Bindi Irwin, stating, “A cup of tea makes everything better,” and doesn’t it? Because a cup of tea welcomes so much more than just a hot beverage, it welcomes a community—a bond created and shared right there between two cups, as sweet as a brew of Darjeeling.
Seeing folks find joy in the knick knacks and decor, sharing stories, and enjoying the food, that’s what I think makes it special,” Carter said. “The Maple Leaf Tea Room is for making memories, and we love being a part of that.”
